iDB Community Forum

Thankee. Vote: umbreonmatt Randomness?

Nooo, Arwen!

Holding my vote temporarily.

Faramir sounds like a night tracker, was Arwen's purpose to give the necklace to someone? D:

It was probably a dream - deliver role. Once they got it who knows what would happen. But it turns out his job was made of phail.

I wonder if Arwen was supposed to give it to Aragorn; then they'd get something special. Just seems almost the most plausible given their history in the movies.. kind of like a Lovers thing. But in the books, I don't think they were as quite loverlike.

The neck-snapping sounds like the work of Gollum, possibly.

I agree with the theory of the two being lovers. Going with the movie, maybe they'd get protection of some kind.

My theory is aragorn is a vigilante, but I do believe the light of the evenstar was meant for FRODO...frodo is sam's friend right? ok I forget

but the point is, the star guides frodo in the cave, not sure how that affects this game, but eitherway, the light is gone.

As for dreamers, looks like none died? So far nobody's contacted me despite me stating...I is innocent!!!!!!!! (and if baddies decide to kill me, well then...too bad for them cuz it doesn't make a difference whether I die or not) so dreamers, contact me if you believe me, and if you don't, then dream me =='
I'm guessing the staff killer with lightning would be sauron/evil wizard.

Gollum sounds right for the neck snapping. He is probably an OMT then as I can't see him working with anyone.

Err, and the lightning sounds like it was done by a wizard. Then it would be saruman or whoever that evil wizard is. I'm not sure what kind of team he could be in.

But that's two attacks, and i'm thinking in a game this size there will be 2 evil teams of 3 and 1 OMT. If Gollum is our OMT, then Saruman is probably in a team, but that leaves one other team, which didn't attack last night. If this is so, then maybe there is a role blocker or something that blocked someone from doing their night action last night, and the person they targeted was the spokesperson. Just a thought.

I don't think Gollum would have a nightkill every night, Gollum is a bit of a mixed bag in the story.

Well, two innocents down, seems like there are two major evil teams, and we're looking for the complement of Garfield's role. No leads yet, so I'll have to Vote:Nobody.

It is possible that Arwen and Aragorn are an avenging siblings type role where Aragorn will now have some kind of power such as a day kill or imunity. The necklace Arwen had means that you can never die, doesn't it? So that would suggest protection.

Aragorn is quite a major character so he could have a power role and it might be unwise for him to reveal who he is.

In the movie, Arwen's evenstar was given to Aragorn, so I don't really know how it can possibly play in this game yet..

I do think that the lightning thing is by Saruman.. my guess is that his evil team consists of some Uruk-Hai, but idk, their killing method would be different no?