iDB Community Forum

Full Version: WW 58: Lord Of the Rings~
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
I don't think we should vote for the dreamer. It really is tough to defend yourself besides stating your role, and since no one has come out saying "omg no u lie" I think he is telling the truth.

You can't fake a dreamer role.

Unvote: Okamoto

|EDIT| I figured that much graphitesmoothie Toungue
Okamoto, who are the two people you've dreamed and contacted, so that we know you are telling the truth?
Vote: Okamoto

What kind of dreamer are you? I've faked a dreamer role myself before, it's not impossible, especially for Oka here.
I'm a bit unsure, technically his role could be plausible but I need to hear a bit more from Oka.

And to the person who chooses who is executed - Katiyu posted a list of the amount of posts people have made a couple of pages or so back. PLEASE choose people who have been very inactive and shady, with only 2 or 3 posts. I think some of our evils are inactive and forgetting to send lists.
Vote: Oka

Graphite already dreams of Sauron's team and the other kills seem to be from OMT only. OMT Dreamer? Lol.
Unvote: Katya
Vote: Okamoto


No response yet, may as well join the bandwagon.
OMT Dreamers are not unheard of --> Serial Killer/Psychologist. In a game of 26 people, I think it would be pretty odd to have one team.. and what two OMTs running about? Numerically the one non-OMT grouping would need to have 4+ members to make the ratio of Innocents : Baddies fall into the standard 2-4:1 ratio... and that is a bit scary. (Assuming of course my math was done even remotely correct. lol.)

Anywhoo, I find it both odd and non-odd that Oka didn't elaborate on his role more.
On the one hand outing yourself as a Dreamer is a pretty darn risky move - yet he didn't say what/whom he dreamt of/for. So that could obviously leave him some wiggle room if he was faking the role. On the other hand, not saying whom/what he dreamt for wouldn't put a HUGe target on his back.. just a comparatively smaller one. Though I'm a bit worried about the quick bandwagoners.

Unvote: Asy
Vote: yoshi


I think your vote is probably one of the shadier of the bandwagonesque votes.

As well... you can fake a Dreamer role. Being a dreamer in no way guarantees that you are innocent.. or atleast will stay that way. I've had a role where I had to dream people to find out whom my teammates were - when I found one I'd join the team.

Edit ~ One more thing. There are standard-esque rules/roles/ideas in WW, but you've gotta look at them as how the MC's sadistic creative mind would twist them to fit the theme or what not.
Yoshi - Graphite dreams for Saruman's team, not Sauron.

But the thing is Katya, i've never seen a role which dreams for more than one OMT. If this isn't the case, then the two people he is dreaming for are a two man team and given who they are this seems incredibly unlikely.

We either have two evil teams of 3 or so, and two OMT's, or 2 teams of 3 and one team of 2.

I'm not taking my vote off oka right now because he hasn't given me much information.

Could the 2 people who he apparently contacted after dreaming of them please say so on the board?

At the moment I think that Oka is one of the two people he claims to be able to dream.

So I think there are 8 evil players, and I bet a lot of them have voted for Okamoto. Personally I think Yoshi is evil as well because of that vote and they have been rather inactive.

EDIT -

Ekul3333 Wrote:
Day Event

Seems Aragorn has been busy... he has once again traveled the paths of the dead... and survived them, bringing out ANOTHER dead person, he has re-emerged with Graphitesmoothie .


I just noticed this. It seems that Aragorn is in fact the resurrector? I wonder what this could mean when Garfield finds Aragorn. Contact each other, rawr.

I still don't get why a bandwagon was started on me because there was no dagger killing last night. I was on the board for Day 1, so if I was in charge of Dagger kills, it would've gone through then. :/

And Katya, I answered Train's inquiry of whom I dream through PM. And since it was already up to half a majority bandwagon, I can't just sit here and praddle vaguely on about being innocent.

Vote: Anvil
His response resembles a baddy's reason to join a bandwagon. A lame excuse that I hadn't responded in a couple hours.
I think it was moreso because there was no neck-snapping last night.

And anyway, can you respond to my other pm?
Yeah, I dunno about this bandwagon on Oka. However for all I know, both i_like_trains_ and Oka are evil, and i_like_trains_ was just trying to save his teammate. Because of the uncertainty, and random kills are going to wipe out the innocents, I will Vote: Nobody
Reference URL's