iDB Community Forum

You mean something like Elf fanboy?

When someone has the Heir role, it doesn't have to be 'the first person to die, you get their role'. It can be the third person, the tenth person, the first female, the first male, the first robot.. etc. I've even put the stipulation in one of my games, that the Heir couldn't inherit a PI role.. so they didn't inherit anything until like the third death. It could've also been an OMT, quite frequently they can have that type of stipulation in their role as a sort of protection against getting killed off early.

I as well, wouldn't be leaping to trust garfield. There isn't exactly any proof that it was an innocent based resurrection. The rezzer shouldn't come out and reveal themselves if it was such, just don't be mass role trading with garfield.

Owlster's role seems believable. I won't get into what he is, because if he wanted y'all to know that he would tell you what it was. But, from what knowledge of LotR I have (with a little help from Google), his character would have a high chance of being included, and thus a poor choice for a fake role.

Also: Just so you people know, I won't reveal any roles (or even the fact that you're innocent) without being given permission to. Just an FYI.

Moar also: Before I forget; HAPPY 1ST ANNIVERSARY OF AMERICAN DIAMOND AND PEARL, EVERYBODY!

Edit: Ah, yeah, hate to say it, but Katya is right. I dunno if there's something I can (or will be able to in the future) to prove it to more than Aragorn, though.

Unvote: Owlstar
Vote: Heidi

There was some pressure on you yesterday, and I think you just ignored it.

edit - i'll also point out that Heidi didn't post yesterday and there was no neck snapping attack.

Unvote: owl
Vote: Heidi Since I won't be around before the next dying time I might as well change it. Also:

Offtopic: FLYERS WON!

Okay, the reason that there was no reaction from me was because I forgot about the game. jlt just gave me a reminder on irc, so yeah. I am an innocent, so to prove that I think that the easiest way would be for me to say who I am.

I am Pippin, a hobbit. And I am innocent

Anyway, Vote: Owl shall b my vote for tonight

Ok, heres what I think:

Garfield is most likely innocent, and being that he is the best bet for trying to weed out the villains until the dreamer finds someone. I think he is probably innocent because it was probably a newer player that did it because everyone was like "ohhh poor arwen..".

Next, to make sure that Garfield is innocent, just dream of him, because only then will you find out the truth before we go into a massive role sharing frenzy.

I think Golleum has the best chance of being the OMT. He is probably the neck snapper with a limited number of attacks or can only attack on odd nights. He wouldn't have any teammates because he is a loner, but there is a possibility of him have like two sides showing the corruption the ring caused.. So there is a possibility of him being the snapper because he totally rung a fish like that in the movie, and then on even nights he is the good Golluem.. I'm not sure how Ekul designed the role though, there are so many options.

Depending on how tonight goes could help or hurt Okamoto since he can't use his role, if there is a missing attack then it's probably him. I'm going to vote for someone whose been flying under the radar, since in my experience that is what villains try to do the most of.

Vote: Yoshi

Garfield just said owlstar's role seemed believable...?

The only characters I can think of that has a dagger would be the Ringwraiths or orcs...

And possibly cause we emphasized that they would get more powers...oops.

Well, yet again, we have nothing to go on. It dreads me to have to pull out the "low-profile/inactive" voting card, but here I am. I haven't seen any notice from Ekul about inactivity. *shrugs*

Vote: Anvil

Unvote: Heidi

So, are you an avenging sibling or something?

Vote: Anvil

weak logic but it's something.

Vote: Owlstar

I'm still leery of how he survived.