iDB Community Forum

Remove
Weapon name: Attack Pea
Reason: How many of these are still in circulation? (Especially compared to SuAP.)

Remove
Weapon name: Blue Scorchstone
Reason: Unless I'm remembering wrong, I checked the Shop Wizard the other day to compare this to Greater Healing Scroll. The prices were fairly close, and the Tarla effect is wearing off of these.

Remove
Weapon name: Bottle of Magic Sand
Reason: Do I really need to give a reason? Overpriced.

Remove
Weapon name: Brain Tree Mace
Reason: 7 expensive, crappy, overpriced icons don't impress anyone nowadays.

Remove
Weapon name: Bzzt Blaster
Reason: It has Light in its attack.

Remove
Weapon name: Cloudy Wand of Storms
Reason: Stone Club and Essence of Esophagor are all this beats, yes? And the Frozen Wand of Crystals does, too, but also hits other stuff?

Remove
Weapon name: Double Dryer
Reason: The 50% reflectors, while cool, are too situational.

Remove
Weapon name: Dual Battle Mirror
Reason: The 50% reflectors, while cool, are too situational.

Remove
Weapon name: Earthen Scorchstone
Reason: Sure it blocks nice types, but who actually uses it?

Remove
Weapon name: Ethereal Sword
Reason: Ineffective.

Remove
Weapon name: Fire Hammer
Reason: Overpriced.

Remove
Weapon name: Halo of Devilpuss
Reason: While I personally like it, it's just too weak nowadays.

Remove
Weapon name: Heavy Blue Tunic
Reason: The defense doesn't impress me, and is limited to Two Player.

Remove
Weapon name: Ice Scorchstone
Reason: Limited to One Player, and weak anyway. How did it ever make it on the list?

Remove
Weapon name: Illusens Earth Potion
Reason: It only "used" to be good.

Remove
Weapon name: Illusens Staff
Reason: There are, what, two of these in the economy? Sure, it's godly, but...

Remove
Weapon name: Jade Scorchstone
Reason: Leaded Elemental Vial has effectively replaced this. The Jade still has the sentimental value, but is (to my knowledge) distinctly more expensive than the LEV.

Remove
Weapon name: Lightning Scroll
Reason: If any six-iconers are going to be on the list, they should be dirt cheap or mono-type.

Remove
Weapon name: Moehog Skull
Reason: Sure, it's godly, but how many are in the economy?

Remove
Weapon name: Scroll of Dark Nova
Reason: If any six-iconers are going to be on the list, they should be dirt cheap or mono-type.

Remove
Weapon name: Seasonal Attack Pea
Reason: How many are still in the economy?

Remove
Weapon name: Shovel Plus
Reason: The 50% reflectors are too situational.

Remove
Weapon name: Sinsis Helm
Reason: This is far more expensive than it used to be, and I'm pretty sure Winged Scarab is cheaper than it used to be.

Remove
Weapon name: Sleep Ray
Reason: The only freezers that really need to be on the list are H4000 Helmet, Freezing Potion (due to price), and Slumberberry Potion (due to uniqueness). Are four icons really that cool? And wasn't this added to the list before the Marbles were released?

Remove
Weapon name: Tooth of Terask
Reason: What does this beat?

Remove
Weapon name: Turbo Flame Reflector
Reason: 50% reflectors are too situational.

Remove
Weapon name: Ultimate Dark Reflectorb
Reason: Ring of the Lost is better against Sword of Skardsen at equal Boosts.

Remove
Weapon name: Ultra Dark Reflectorb
Reason: 50% reflectors are too situational.

Remove
Weapon name: Ultra Dual Shovel
Reason: How many active Two Player battlers still use Peas?

Remove
Weapon name: Virtupets X-514 Super Shield
Reason: Are there actually people that think this shield is good?

Remove
Weapon name: Wand of the Dark Faerie
Reason: Are there any of these in the economy? Sure, it's godly, but...

Remove
Weapon name: Werelupe Claw Necklace
Reason: Who actually thinks this is good?

Remove
Weapon name: Zapatron 2000
Reason: I don't know what it blocks, and it uses Light.

Weapon name: Brain Tree Mace
Reason: This was good years ago, not now with the 9 iconers.

Weapon name: Ethereal Sword
Reason: There are better light defense options out there.

Weapon name: Fire Hammer
Reason: 9 iconers > 7-9 icons for less.

Weapon name: Halo Of Devilpuss
Reason: Not strong enough in the current BD setting.

Weapon name: Ice Scorchstone
Reason: Just... ew! Jade Elixir/Lucky Robots Foot are much better if you want a full heal.

Weapon name: Tooth Of Terask
Reason: Scarab Ring is still better, there are better options for dark defense.

Weapon name: Zapatron 2000
Reason:Golden Compass is the new standard.

Weapon name: Rod of Dark Nova
Reason: If other "dream level" weapons are going to be on the list, this should be there as well.

Weapon name: Ultra Bubble Gun
Reason:Incredibly hard to block and still underrated today.

Weapon name: Jade Elixir
Reason:It's often cheaper than Lucky Robots Foot.

Weapon name: Bag of Healing Dust
Reason:Just to get rid of the Ice Scorchstone! And it's a reasonable healer for lab rats.

I know we're only supposed to suggest weapons, but I want to suggest adding a "dream level" weapon section after the "10 million NP+" section. Nearly everyone dreams of owning such items (The pea set, RoDN, M-skull, I-staff, WotDF etc) but know they never will. It would be nice to have all of them in one spot for people to drool over... and it'll let newbies know that they can't buy them for "10 mil"

Remove
Weapon: Illusens Earth Potion
Reason:I know 7-9 icons is great for 1k but it is far too weak to be a once per battle bomb. You'll outgrow this weapon in a week or less and it's only good on the most beginner levels like facing mr. chuckles for the first time.

Weapon: Scroll of Dark Nova
Reason:Due to avatar inflation this is more expensive then it should be. It costs about 16k for 6 attack icons when scarab ring costs about 2k for 6 attack and 6 defence

Weapon: Air Faerie Crown
Reason:Stone club and ice club are 9-iconers for about 70-75k. Scarab ring defends 6 icons, even more than this defends, for about 2k. Yet this costs 2 MILLION. Rip-off, much?

Weapon: Ice Scorchstone
Reason:I understand this can full heal for only about 2 million but it only heals a quarter of the time. Wasting 4 turns in a battle trying to heal will almost definately kill you. I guess you can withdraw and try again in 1-p but in 2-p it's almost useless

Weapon name: Mask Of Coltzan
Reason:Basically the same breakdown as air faerie crown. You can get an 8-icon attack for about 40k and a 11-icon defense for about 30k. Sure it gets bonus for being put together into one weapon but is that really worth an extra 3.5 million?

Weapon: Fire Muffin
Reason:12 icons for a single use item? You can do better than that. Get a Shooting Star Muffin

Add
Weapon name: Von Roo Dice
Reason:This is great for 1-p because if you don't get a max hit you can withdraw. It can do 9 icons for only 6-9k which is a great deal compared to the 9-icon era, ice club, stone club, Psellias Fighting Fan, etc. It averages about 8 icons for under 10k, this weapon is outstanding

Weapon name: Carrotblade
Reason:Just like von roo dice, this is great for 1-p because if you don't get a max hit you can withdraw. It can do 19 icons for 5-9 mill, a little over half the cost of the common sword of skardsen

Weapon name: 17-Pound Trout
Reason:This was my first upgrade from the scarab ring. It averages about 7 icons for a highly affordable price, only 10k, and just like the von roo dice you can withdraw until you get 9 icons in 1-p which really is a bargain for it's price

Weapon name: Glittery Faerie Dust
Reason:This is great in 1-p because 15 of 1 icon is almost impossible for most challengers to block. Also great for 2-p because it is random and your opponent will not know how to stop it unless they use a multiple type blocker like ghostkershield or faerie tabard. To top it off, it's at an affordable price

Weapon name: Rainbow Clockwork Grundo
Reason:This is extremely underrated, it's perfect if you want to upgrade your honey potion but can't afford the jump to ghostkerbomb

Weapon name: Mystical White Cloak
Reason:I have this in my set and it's never let me down. Paired with leaf shield, this covers 6 of the 7 icons and a reasonable amount of each of those icons for only 50k.

Weapon name: Portable Kiln
Reason:Sure you can get 11 iconers for about 1.5 mill these days but this is mono-type and and almost perfect as far as strategy goes. This gets all 11 icons through the common ghostkershield and 6 through the faerie tabard. This makes it tremendous in 2-p and in 1-p 11 icons is a lot of raw power and of 1 icon there is only a slim chance it will get blocked.

Weapon: Shooting Star Muffin
Reason:This is single use and was given out by the advent calender so the price will just keep rising. However for now it is just about 3.5k for a 15 icon single use and everyone should use these in important battles like DoN.

Weapon: Jhudoras Wand
Reason:Block all air, reflect 75% light AND do 8 icons for the same price as a ghostkersword? This weapon is great and semi-affordable

Weapon: Enchanted Kiko Squeeze Toy
Reason:This is one of, if not the cheapest, full icon blocker. If you know your opponent will use a water attack ou can fully bock it for only 350k.