iDB Community Forum

Oh, i understand, =p. Well, it was a fun game, i'd gladly do another one. And also, I gave a list to chicken before I died saying who to go after, and luckily, some of them were right =).

jakachuy Wrote:Oh, i understand, =p. Well, it was a fun game, i'd gladly do another one. And also, I gave a list to chicken before I died saying who to go after, and luckily, some of them were right =).

Yes, that was key. If I remember correctly Jaka was pretty wrong about who the WBs were (I think he said Wiz kid and seashell) but for the RBs he identified Kuge and Ooga. This was extremely important because at about the same time, when I asked on thread for innocents to contact me, Lacka had contacted me saying she was the deconverter. With Jaka's info I was able to advise that Kuge be converted. He had actually also contacted me claiming he was a plain innocent, which was partially true. What he said seemed to ring true, so I guessed that he had once been a plain innocent before being converted. Anyway, that still left one unidentified RB. TMC was obviously one of them, Ooga made a 2nd. But there was still another one. I spend alot of time pondering who he was, suspecting PK and wiz_kid mostly. For along time I didn't question Q77's claimed role. I had been gone for 4 days without internet, and although I did read through the game thread after I came back, I basically accepted what was then the conventonal wisdom that q77 was neutral. Then he offers to shoot the people I asked him too. So I contact him identifying who the RBs were. The next day he lies on thread about what I had told him so it became obvious he was evil. When I started thinking about him I realised there was no reason to believe the role he claimed. Realising q77 was evil pretty much sealed the RBs fate.

Anyway, I would like to comment that that strategy of claiming to be neutral when your evil is a good one. It worked great for q77, and I myself used it in a recent game. Even when I was dead and identified as a baddie people still were referring to me as a neutral.

And even then chicken, when i sent that to you, i thought RB and cults were on a different team .

I really was a townsperson when i told ya y'know!

chicken Wrote:TMC was obviously one of them

You had no idea untill I didn't vote Q77. That was a HUGE let down because I only did it to have him saved, but he failed to kill someone off who had voted on him, which doomed us all entirely. I knew the best roles, I knew from the first dya I came back. It was dificult taking someone out with...4 days of protection?

I don't know what your talking about, but I know you didn't have 4 days of protection. But, yes, you were obviously evil before that. First of all you were the obvious choice, in fact the RBs almost had to convert you to have any hope of winning. Secondly I had asked you to use your kills the day after the convert occured, and you hadn't objected. But no kills occured. BTW, not voting q77 probably wasn't the greatest idea, since we already had majority anyway I'm pretty sure, and it made it very obvious that you two were on the same team. This made it even more obvious q77 was evil, and when he died an RB, that you were also one.

I wonder if telling TMC to kill off 2/3 or as many innocents as possible and then converting him at night would have worked...it would have been a lot better for the RBs...

Well, Q77, I was going for you that day, but then chicken told me not to.

Yes, I still believed in q77's neutral story. It would have been a bad idea for TMC to trust you because then, the most logical move for you guys would have been to doublecross him and convert someone else instead. But anyway, getting back to the point, telling TMC to wait a day was a big mistake by me, because then he got converted without his kills being used. Not sure what I was thinking really, I'm lucky it didn't cost us the game.

Was a good game, a tad slow in the final part.

The RB was a little overpowered in my opinion, but meh, is kinda my fault since I had some issues in my school

I'll like other game, with the extra crew member.