iDB Community Forum

Quote:and a lot like Kagemucha's.

Mine came first

There, scores are up.

Team Hugh:
Kagemucha - Pink Perfection
sweet, simple, and it is alliteration.... almost perfecto... 9/10

Kugetsu - Wit on a stick.
hmmmm..... i see what you were trying to get at... but if i seea guy put on some lipstick, i don't get the feeling he has more wit than me.... i have mixed feelings on this one.... 7.5/10

Jlt1990 - Beauty That Allures..
hmmm.... i really like this... i think this fits great! 8.5/10

Benladesh - Kiss Me
lolz.... you sound like notinuse! i'll give you an extra .5 for spunkiness... 7.5/10

Team Laurie:
Ryguy - Who said pink was SOOO last season?
a little long, but cute... i'll take it ... 8/10

seashell_js - a touch of glamour...
very nice touch...simple and short but packs a punch 9/10

notinuse - Pretty in pink
a hint of alliteration, and it's short simple and sweet.... 8.5/10

sirclucky - I don’t make the beauty. *fades* I just help beauty in others shine.

hmmm.... sounds a little bruce lee-ish.... but very optomistic, and for being so optimistic i'll give you a 9.... 9/10

Note:Sorry, I will not be giving in-depth ratings. *tired* I do realize that everything is dragging on and on, but all will change starting next round!

Team Hugh:
Kagemucha - Pink Perfection
Simple, I like the double "P", it feel like it's missing something somehow though. Perhaps "Perfect Pink Perfection"? Good job though. - 8/10

Kugetsu - Wit on a stick.
Honestly, I dont like this one. People might go "huh" if you didn't explain it to them. If it were a more generally known fact, I would've been more generous. However, I do like the rhyme and the catchiness of it. - 5/10

Jlt1990 - Beauty That Allures..
I'm kinda on the fence on this one, on one hand, it seems too serious for the signature, though I do like it. I like the word "allure", it's not common and it fits in with the lipstick. - 8/10

Benladesh - Kiss Me
Nobody saw this one coming. It's short and to the point, however, it would've worked so much better with lips instead of lipstick. This one is just okay in my opinion. - 7/10


Team Laurie:
Ryguy - Who said pink was SOOO last season?
I'm glad you took a different spin on it, but this doesn't quite work for me. Like you said, the judges will either love it, or hate it. - 5/10

seashell_js - a touch of glamour...
This one does fit the signature perfectly. It does seem bland somehow though, as if something is missing. But at least it fits. - 8/10

notinuse - Pretty in pink
Pretty much what I've said for Kagemucha. This one seems to fit a little bit more though, as you've used "pretty" which, in my opinion, fits the signature better. Although, there's nobody that's really wearing the lipstick... so there's nothing in pink. =\ - 8/10

sirclucky - I don’t make the beauty. *fades* I just help beauty in others shine.
I think this could've been worded to make a very nice subtext. However, this is the most original, fitting subtext I've seen this round. Good job! - 8.5/10

Sorry Kugetsu, you are eliminated this round.

Yay! Highest total scores! I knew that subtext was a winner even if I didn't work it perfectly

Round 4




Team Hugh:
Benladesh
notinuse
Ryguy
sirclucky

Team Laurie:
Kagemucha
Jlt1990
seashell2_js
Filler

--

Subtexts will have to be in by March 11th.

I saw that and thought "The Sound Of White"... then realised it was the name of an album But seeing as I'm a judge it doesn't matter

I like the signature though, it's nice and simple.

Quote:Sheet music

Quote:The silence of another gone

I just found out that Dana Reeve died. She was a great person, may she rest in peace.

Quote:The Sound of Sweet Simplicity